California Court of Appeal June 7, 1999, F027142 (N.T. Hill Inc. v. City of Fresno)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-06-1999

Opinion

DIBIASO, Acting P. J.

Plaintiff N.T. Hill Inc., doing business as R. J. Hill Company (Hill), appeals from a judgment in favor of defendant City of Fresno (City) in a lawsuit brought by Hill to challenge the legality of certain water capacity fees assessed against a residential subdivision being developed by Hill. We will reverse. In the published portion of this opinion we compare Government Code sections 66020 and 66022 and describe their respective applications with respect to fees of the type in issue.

Statement of Case and Facts

In June 1994, Hill submitted a vesting tentative subdivision map application to the City for the development of Golden Dawn Ranch, a proposed residential subdivision of 449 single-family homes on approximately 109 acres known as tract No. 4677. The tract was located in an area identified by the City as “water supply area ‘501.’ ” On October 5, 1994, the City approved Hill’s vesting tentative map for the development, on the condition (among others) that Hill pay a water well fee or, in the alternative, dedicate a well site and construct a water well and wellhead treatment facilities. Hill chose to pay the fee, which was calculated to be $253 per dwelling unit. By mid-October 1994, Hill had appealed the planning commission’s decision to attach the water supply conditions to the approval of Hill’s tentative map.

On January 7, 1995, during the pendency of Hill’s appeal, the Fresno City Council adopted ordinance No. 95-4, along with a contemporaneously adopted resolution (No. 95-15), which increased residential subdivision water fees in area No. 501 from $253 to $1,416 per dwelling unit. The

*981

ordinance became effective on March 19, 1995. The justification for the increase was the council’s determination that groundwater contamination existed in water supply area No. 501. Another resolution (No. 95-18), adopted by the City concurrently with ordinance No.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.