Court of Appeals of Arizona December 7, 1999, 1 CA-CR 98-0973, 1 CA-CR 98-0977 to 1 CA-CR 98-0979 (State v. Bonnewell)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-12-1999
OPINION
RYAN, Judge.
¶ 1 Kurt Bonnewell, Lauralu Harkins, Lee P. Hulsey, and Walter John Randall (“Defendants”) were convicted of setting a leghold trap on public land in violation of Arizona Revised Statutes Annotated (“A.R.S.”) section iY-SOlfDXl),
1
a class two misdemeanor. On appeal, they argue that the statute is a special or local law in violation of the Arizona Constitution and that it violates the equal protection clauses of the Arizona and United States Constitutions.
¶ 2 We hold that A.R.S. section 17-301(D) is not an unconstitutional local or special law because it rationally furthers a legitimate governmental purpose, applies to all persons in Arizona, and benefits no static class of individuals. We also hold that the statute does not violate the equal protection clauses of either the Arizona Constitution or the United States Constitution because it is rationally related to a legitimate governmental purpose. We therefore affirm.
Background
¶ 3 In the November 1994 general election, voters passed Proposition 201, which was codified as A.R.S. section 17-301(D). The pertinent part of the statute made unlawful the taking of wildlife on public lands by leghold trap.
2
The statute makes exceptions
*594
for the use of traps by government officials to protect against threats to human health or safety, or for research, falconry, relocation of wildlife, or rodent control.
See
A.R.S. § 17-301(D)(1), (3), (4), and (5) (Supp.1998). According to the pamphlet issued by the Secretary of State on the 1994 Ballot Propositions, the purposes of the initiative were, among others, to prevent cruelty to wildlife on public lands and to prevent injuries to pets, children, and adults using public lands for recreation.
¶4 Defendants were each charged with setting a leghold trap in violation of A.R.S. section 17-301(D).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit