Ohio Court of Appeals September 16, 1999, No. 98AP-1266. (State Ex Rel. Ertz v. Indus. Comm'n., Unpublished Decision (9-16-1999))
Also known as
United States · · · 16-09-1999
IN MANDAMUS ON OBJECTIONS TO THE MAGISTRATE'S DECISION Relator, Edna Ertz, has filed this original action requesting that this court issue a writ of mandamus ordering respondent Industrial Commission of Ohio ("commission") to vacate its January 10, 1997 and August 12, 1997 orders, which overruled her motion to depose Dr. Greer and denied her application for permanent total disability ("PTD") compensation, to direct the commission to grant her motion to depose Dr. Greer, and to conduct a new hearing on the merits of her application for PTD compensation. In the alternative, relator requests this court find that Dr. Greer's report is legally insufficient and to either find that relator is entitled to PTD compensation or to require the commission to secure a new psychiatric examination and to conduct further proceedings. This matter was referred to a court-appointed magistrate, pursuant to Civ.R. 53 and Loc.R. 12(M) of the Tenth District Court of Appeals. The magistrate issued a decision, including findings of fact and conclusions of law, and has recommended that this court deny relator's request for a writ of mandamus. Relator filed objections to the magistrate's decision. Relator first argues that the magistrate erred in finding that no substantial disparity existed between the reports of Drs. Greer and Nims, and, therefore, she should have been permitted to depose Dr. Greer. Ohio Adm. Code 4121-3-09(A)(6)(d) provides that a party may depose a doctor where a substantial disparity exists in the reports of examining physicians and where the commission's award was predicated on one report to the exclusion of others. Dr. Greer determined that relator had a twenty percent permanent impairment based only upon her psychological condition. However, Dr. Nims stated in his report: It is my impression that based upon a combination of her physical and psychiatric conditions that she is permanently and totally unable to sustain any ruminative [sic] employment. [Emphasis added.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit