United States Tax Court June 18, 1999, 16796-97 (George W. Guill v. Commissioner)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-06-1999

112 T.C. No. 22

UNITED STATES TAX COURT

GEORGE W. GUILL, Petitioner v.

COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE, Respondent

Docket No. 16796-97. Filed June 18, 1999.

P, an independent contractor, commenced a lawsuit

against D, alleging that D was liable to P for breach

of contract and conversion arising out of P's work for

D. As to the conversion claim, the jury awarded P

actual and punitive damages, together with interest and

costs. P received the award in 1992, and, from this

amount, P paid his attorneys their fees and the court

costs (collectively, legal costs). P deducted the

legal costs on his 1992 Schedule C, Profit or Loss From

Business, reporting that the costs arose out of his

sole-proprietor business, and he reported the actual

damages on that schedule as income from the business.

P did not include the punitive damages in his 1992

gross income. R determined that the legal costs were

deductible as a nonbusiness itemized deduction on

Schedule A, Itemized Deductions, and that the punitive

damages were reportable as nonbusiness income. R

concedes that the legal costs are a business expense to

the extent they are attributable to P's recovery of the

- 2 -

actual damages. R asserts that the remaining legal

costs are a nonbusiness itemized deduction because they

are attributable to P's recovery of the punitive

damages. P and R agree that the punitive damages are

includable in P's business income if the legal costs

are a business expense.

Held: All of the legal costs are attributable to

P's trade or business; hence, the legal costs are all

deductible on Schedule C as a business expense.

Bobby Wayne Enlow, for petitioner.

Jeanne Gramling, for respondent.

OPINION

LARO, Judge: This case is before the Court fully

stipulated. See Rule 122. George W. Guill petitioned the Court

to redetermine deficiencies of $100,916 and $434 in his 1992 and

1993 Federal income tax, respectively.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.