Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit May 11, 1999, 97-5143 (Henry Hendler, Paul Garrett and Tillie Goldring as Trustees for Henry Hendler and Irving Gronsky v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-05-1999
PLAGER, Circuit Judge.
In this takings case, we approach the final chapter in a decade-long dispute between the landowners and the Government. The dispute was initiated when the Government entered upon the land of the plaintiffs, without their consent and over their objection, for the purpose of sinking wells for monitoring of ground water migration from adjacent properties. Over time the Government continued to establish additional wells and to service them, all without payment to the landowners for the use of their property. The landowners sued, claiming inverse condemnation.
After several false starts at the trial level,
see Hendler v. United States,
11 Cl.Ct. 91 (1986)
(“Hendler I”)] Hendler v. United States,
19 Cl.Ct. 27 (1989)
(“Hendler II
”), this court determined that plaintiffs had a good cause of action. We held that the Government, however well motivated and however important its cause, must adhere to fundamental Constitutional principles: if private property is taken for public use, just compensation must be paid.
See Hendler v. United States,
952 F.2d 1364 (Fed.Cir.1991)
(“Hendler III”).
The cause was remanded to the trial court for further proceedings.
Subsequently, the Court of Federal Claims undertook to determine, on the facts of the case, what was the just compensation mandated by the Constitution. After trials on liability theories and damages issues, the Court of Federal Claims determined that plaintiffs ultimately were due no compensation.
See Hendler v. United States,
36 Fed.Cl. 574 (1996)
(“Hendler IV”); Hendler v. United States,
38 Fed.Cl. 611 (1997)
(“Hendler
V”). Plaintiffs appeal that judgment, and the findings that underlay it.
BACKGROUND
The detailed background of the case is described in the prior opinions,
Hendler IV.
We provide here a brief overview. The subject property is an approximately 100-acre tract of land in southern California, near the city of Riverside.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit