District Court of Appeal of Florida February 10, 1999, Nos. 98-0310, 98-1629 (St. Mary's Hospital, Inc. v. Schocoff)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-02-1999
OWEN, WILLIAM C., Jr. Senior Judge.
A summary judgment was entered for the defendant on its defense of accord and satisfaction. Because there remained a genuine factual issue on the parties’ intent, an essential element of the defense, we reverse.
St. Mary’s Hospital, Inc., (“St.Mary’s”) sued a patient’s health insurer to recover charges incurred by the patient during his hospitalization, alleging both breach of contract1 and promissory estoppel. The insurer’s affirmative defense of accord and satisfaction was based on St. Mary’s having deposited the insurer’s check for benefits enclosed in a transmittal letter containing the following language:
After a careful review of the above claim we’ve determined benefits would be payable.
Please let me explain what the policy allows for this claim.
The medical facts we received indicate [the patient] was admitted on February 15, 1994 due to a suicide attempt. Therefore, the first date of this confinement is not covered. The remaining days of the hospital stay are considered as loss due to mental illness.
This policy allows up to 30 days inpatient hospital expense for mental conditions. We had previously paid 23 days for [the patient’s] March 29 to April 21 stay at Bethesda Memorial Hospital. We are now paying benefits for the remaining 7 days for the stay at St. Mary’s Hospital. No further benefits will be payable.
If we can be of further service please feel free to write or call.
(Emphasis added).
An explanation of benefits, attached to the check, stated “the plan specified room & board rate is the maximum amount payable” and “the maximum for this type of service has been reached.”
In Chassan Professional Wallcovering, Inc. v. Victor Frankel, Inc., 608 So.2d 91, 93 (Fla.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit