Louisiana Court of Appeal July 21, 1999, No. 98-CA-0286, 98-CA-0351, 98-CA-0451, 98-CA-0453, 98-CA-0615, 98-CA-0616, 98-CA-0664 and 98-CA-2754 (Adams v. Airco Welding Products Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-07-1999

hKLEES, Chief Judge.

These consolidated appeals1 arise from several judgments rendered by various divisions of Civil District Court granting the Rules to Tax Costs filed by Dale N. Atkins in her capacity as Clerk of Court. Plaintiffs in these several lawsuits are individuals who allegedly suffered personal injuries as a result of job-related exposure to asbestos containing materials. Plaintiffs’ claims were cumulated into these various lawsuits, and numerous corporate defendants were named in the pleadings. Certain defendants filed various exceptions and answers to plaintiffs’ claims, and one filing fee was remitted for each answer filed. The Rules to Tax Costs were subsequently brought against several defense attorneys who had previously filed answers on behalf of their respective clients to these multi-party lawsuits. The Clerk sought from the defense attorneys additional filing fees based on the number of claims filed in each petition. These matters were set for hearing, and four divisions of the trial court rendered separate personal | ¡judgments against the defense attorneys named in the rules. The defense attorneys now appeal from these judgments.

The issue presented for our review is whether the trial courts erred in ordering the defense attorneys personally to pay retroactive filing fees for answers previously filed in these multi-party lawsuits. For reasons stated more fully herein, we reverse the judgments of the lower courts.

Applicable Law

According to the pleadings filed by the Clerk of Court, the Rules to Tax Costs were filed on the basis of La. C.C.P. art. 1920, which provides:

Unless the judgment provides otherwise, costs shall be paid by the party cast, and may be taxed by a rule to show cause.

Except as otherwise provided by law, the court may render judgment for costs, or any part thereof, against any party, as it may consider equitable.

Generally, the enumeration of fees for the services of Clerks of Court is contained in La.R.S. 13:1213.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.