Court of Civil Appeals of Alabama June 4, 1999, 2980337 (Southern United Fire Insurance v. Willingham)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-06-1999

lead-opinion

MONROE, Judge.

The issue in this case is whether an insurance policy issued by Southern United Fire Insurance Company to Dorothy G. Willingham provided Dorothy’s children Janice Thomas, Jimmie Thomas, and Tar-sha Willingham with uninsured-motorist coverage.

Janice Thomas, Jimmie Thomas, and Tarsha Willingham were injured an automobile accident with an uninsured motorist on December 18, 1996. Janice was driving a 1986 Honda Accord automobile, which she owned and which was apparently not insured. Jimmie and Tarsha were passengers. The three filed a claim based on their personal injuries, under their mother’s insurance policy with Southern United.

Southern United filed a declaratory judgment action asking the court to hold that it was not obligated to pay the children benefits under the uninsured-motorist-coverage provision in its insurance policy issued to their mother. The children filed a counterclaim, seeking damages. Southern United filed a motion for a summary judgment, which the court denied. The parties agreed to a stipulation of facts, and the court, using those facts, entered a judgment in favor of the children on Southern United’s claim for declaratory relief and in favor of the children on their *504counterclaim. The court assessed total damages of $13,500 — $5,000 to Janice, $8,800 to Jimmie, and $4,700 to Tarsha. Southern United appeals.

When the facts are undisputed and the controversy involves a question of law for the trial court’s determination, on appeal this court will review the application of the law to the facts, and, in such a case, the trial court’s judgment is not accorded a presumption of correctness. Allstate Ins. Co. v. Skelton, 675 So.2d 377, 379 (Ala.1996).

Southern United argues that the children are not included as insureds in their mother’s uninsured motorist coverage provision in her insurance policy. The pertinent provision provides:

“2. Who is Insured? — The following are insureds under ‘III.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.