District Court, D. Kansas May 11, 1999, Civ.A. No. 98-2222—GTV (Turnbull v. Topeka State Hospital)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-05-1999
MEMORANDUM AND ORDER
RUSHFELT, United States Magistrate Judge.
The court has before it four motions: Plaintiffs Motion to Compel Discovery (doc. 55); Defendants Kansas’ and Topeka State Hospital’s Motion for Protective Order (doc. 59); Defendants Kansas’ and Topeka State Hospital’s Motion for Protective Order Pro*648hibiting Ex Parte Communications (doc. 60); and Joint Request for Hearing on Plaintiffs Motion to Compel Discovery and Defendants’ Motions for Protective Order (doc. 80). The Joint Request simply asks for oral argument on the other three motions. The court will overrule the request for oral argument as unnecessary. The parties have adequately briefed their motions.
Plaintiffs Motion to Compel Discovery (doc. 55) seeks an order to compel “defendants’ management witnesses to answer deposition questions pertaining to defendants’ Security Management Reports, Risk Management Committee Minutes and/or Executive Committee Minutes.” Plaintiff also asks for her attorneys fees and costs associated with this motion. She further asks that defendants bear the costs of reconvening the depositions of two management employees of Topeka State Hospital, Randy Proctor and Magdalene Kovach.
The principal dispute upon this motion involves the applicability of privileges provided by Kansas statute K.S.A. 65-4925. During depositions defense counsel instructed Mr. Proctor and Ms. Kovach not to answer questions pertaining to documents previously produced by defendants during discovery. The documents include Security Management Reports, Risk Management Committee minutes, and Executive Committee Minutes. Defense counsel based his instructions to the deponents upon grounds that the statute provides privileges against discovery of the documents and against testimony by committee members who attended the meetings reflected by the minutes and reports. Plaintiff contends the statutory privileges do not apply to this case, because her claim arises under federal and not state law.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit