District Court, S.D. West Virginia July 26, 1999, No. CIV A 2:97-0978 (West Virginia-Ohio Valley Area I.B.E.W. Welfare Fund v. American Tobacco Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-07-1999

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

HADEN, Chief Judge.

Pending is Plaintiffs motion for voluntary dismissal without prejudice pursuant to Rule 41(a)(2), Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. The Court GRANTS the motion as moulded.

Defendants mount a significant challenge to Plaintiffs motion. They oppose not dismissal, but rather dismissal without prejudice. They request the Court (1) dismiss the case with prejudice or, in the alternative, (2) allow the case to proceed to summary judgment.

Rule 41(a)(2) provides, in pertinent part, as follows:

Except as provided in paragraph (1) of this subdivision of this rule, an action shall not be dismissed at the plaintiffs instance save upon order of the court and wpon such terms and conditions as the court deems proper.

Fed.R.Civ.P. 41(a)(2). The 'Court discussed recently this area of the law in Bragg v. Robertson, 54 F.Supp.2d 658 (S.D.W.Va.1999):

Typically, a motion for dismissal without prejudice should not be denied “absent substantial prejudice to the defendant,” Andes v. Versant Corp., 788 F.2d 1033, 1036 (4th Cir.1986). Comparatively, actual legal prejudice is the standard rather than the mere prospect of suffering subsequent lawsuits, Davis v. USX Corp., 819 F.2d 1270, 1274-75 (4th Cir.1987).

Id., 54 F.Supp.2d at 660-661.

Davis observed “It is well established that, for purposes of Rule 41(a)(2), prejudice to the defendant does not result from the prospect of a second lawsuit.” Davis v. USX Corp., 819 F.2d at 1274. The Court of Appeals further stated “Indeed, in cases involving the scope of state law, courts should readily approve of dismissal when a plaintiff wishes to pursue a claim in state court. In this case, for example, a lawsuit in state court is preferable because it would allow the courts of South Carolina„to resolve a difficult question of state law.”1 Id. at 1275 (emphasis added).

Defendants assert Plaintiffs proposed dismissal would prejudice them.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.