District Court, N.D. Ohio March 16, 1999, No. 3:98CV7439 (Libbey Glass, Inc. v. Oneida)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-03-1999
*344ORDER
CARR, District Judge.
This is a trade dress case in which the parties dispute demands for discovery by the plaintiff, Libbey Glass, Inc. (Libbey). The defendant, Oneida, Ltd. (Oneida), opposes the demands. Following submission of letter briefs and a telephone conference, the issues raised by Libbey are decisional.
Background
The gravamen of Libbey’s complaint is that Pasabahce Cam Sanayii VE Ticaret A.S. (Pasabahce) is making, and Oneida is selling, glassware that is duplicative of seven of Lib-bey’s best-selling patterns.
Resolution of the pending discovery dispute requires an understanding of the relationship between Oneida, Pasabahce, and Norbert Ullman, a middleman in the dealings between Oneida and Pasabahce. Oneida is a major supplier of flatware and tableware to the foodservice industry (i.e., restaurants, hotels, and other institutional users of glassware). Oneida is undertaking to increase its presence in the market by offering glassware as well.
To attract customers, including customers who have purchased or may purchase glassware from Libbey (which historically has had the largest market share), Oneida has contracted with Pasabahce, a Turkish manufacturer of glassware, to purchase several lines of glassware. Among the lines to be supplied by Pasabahce to Oneida are seven styles that Libbey claims are duplicative of its most popular glassware lines.
Ullmann, a citizen and resident of the Federal Republic of Germany, appears to have played an important role in the development of the present supplier/purchaser relationship between Oneida and Pasabahce. The parties dispute the legal consequences of that role and Ullmann’s relationship with Oneida. Libbey claims that Ullmann is and has been a “managing agent” of Oneida as that term is used in Fed.R.Civ.P. 30(b). If so, he may be produced for deposition in this country.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit