South Dakota Supreme Court April 14, 1999, None (Coffee Cup Fuel Stops)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-04-1999

Unified Judicial System Formatting provided courtesy of State Bar of South Dakota and South Dakota Continuing Legal Education, Inc. 222 East Capitol Ave. Pierre, SD 57501-2596 COFFEE CUP FUEL STOPS & CONVENIENCE STORES, INC., a corporation, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. DIANE L. DONNELLY and GEORGE DONNELLY, Trustees of the Diane L. Donnelly Living Trust, and Diane Donnelly, individually, Defendants and Appellees. South Dakota Supreme Court Appeal from the First Judicial Circuit, Union County, SD Hon. Richard Bogue, Judge #20611--Reversed Carlyle Richards, Richards & Oliver, Aberdeen, SD Attorneys for Plaintiff and Appellant. Gary J. Pashby, Lisa Hansen Marso Boyce, Murphy, McDowell & Greenfield, Sioux Falls, SD Attorneys for Defendants and Appellees. Considered on Briefs Feb 24, 1999; Opinion Filed Apr 14, 1999 MILLER, Chief Justice. [¶1] Coffee Cup Fuel Stops and Convenience Stores, Inc. brought an action against Diane and George Donnelly seeking specific performance of an option contract to purchase real property. The trial court granted summary judgment to Donnellys. We reverse and remand. FACTS [¶2] Coffee Cup, a closely held South Dakota corporation, is engaged in the convenience store and petroleum business in South Dakota, North Dakota, and Wyoming. One of its South Dakota businesses is located in Union County, near Vermillion, at the southwest corner of the junction of Interstate 29 and South Dakota Highway 50. [¶3] In 1994, Coffee Cup became interested in purchasing land adjacent to its Union County facility. It contacted the South Dakota Department of Transportation (DOT), which owned a fourteen-acre parcel of property east of the facility. DOT was not interested in selling the property outright, but indicated it would consider an exchange for similar property. [¶4] Tom Heinz, one of Coffee Cup's shareholders and directors, began searching for available property to purchase and then exchange with DOT.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.