Supreme Court of Virginia June 9, 2000, Record 992098 (Decker v. Harlan)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-06-2000

Present: All the Justices

GLADYS JANET DECKER

OPINION BY JUSTICE LEROY R. HASSELL, SR.

v. Record No. 992098 June 9, 2000

THOMAS D. HARLAN, II, ET AL.

FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE CITY OF HAMPTON

Wilford J. Taylor, Jr., Judge

I.

In this appeal, we consider whether Code § 15.2-1809 bars

a plaintiff's tort claims against the City of Hampton, which

operates the Hampton Coliseum, and its employee, a building

mechanic assigned to work at that facility. Code § 15.2-1809

states in relevant part:

"No city or town which operates any park,

recreational facility or playground shall be liable

in any civil action or proceeding for damages

resulting from any injury to the person or from a

loss of or damage to the property of any person

caused by any act or omission constituting ordinary

negligence on the part of any officer or agent of

such city or town in the maintenance or operation of

any such park, recreational facility or playground.

Every such city or town shall, however, be liable in

damages for the gross negligence of any of its

officers or agents in the maintenance or operation

of any such park, recreational facility or

playground."

II.

Plaintiff, Gladys Janet Decker, filed her motion for

judgment against the City of Hampton and its employee, Thomas

D. Harlan, II. Decker alleged that she sustained personal

injuries when a refuse truck, operated by Harlan, collided

with her van. The defendants, relying upon Code § 15.2-1809,

filed a plea of statutory immunity. The circuit court

conducted an evidentiary hearing, sustained the plea, and,

among other things, entered a judgment in favor of the

defendants. Decker appeals.

The following evidence was adduced at the evidentiary

hearing. On October 29, 1996, Decker was driving a van on

Magruder Boulevard near its intersection with Semple Farm Road

in the City of Hampton. While she was in her van, stopped at

a traffic light, a refuse truck operated by Harlan collided

with Decker's van, injuring her.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.