Court of Appeals of Virginia February 22, 2000, 1689982 (Monte Pulley v. Commonwealth of Virginia)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-02-2000

COURT OF APPEALS OF VIRGINIA

Present: Judge Bray, Senior Judges Cole and Overton

Argued at Richmond, Virginia

MONTE PULLEY

OPINION BY

v. Record No. 1689-98-2 JUDGE RICHARD S. BRAY

FEBRUARY 22, 2000

COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA

FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF BRUNSWICK COUNTY

James A. Luke, Judge

David B. Hargett (Joseph D. Morrissey;

Morrissey & Hershner, PLC, on brief), for

appellant.

Virginia B. Theisen, Assistant Attorney

General (Mark L. Earley, Attorney General, on

brief), for appellee.

Monte Pulley (defendant) was convicted by a jury of

manslaughter. On appeal, he complains that the trial court

erroneously (1) denied a mistrial after a Commonwealth witness

referenced defendant's post-Miranda invocation of his right to

counsel, and (2) refused to permit impeachment of a Commonwealth

witness. We disagree and affirm the conviction.

I.

During trial of defendant before a jury on indictments

alleging first-degree murder and use of a firearm in the

commission of such offense, the Commonwealth, on direct

examination, inquired of Police Investigator Mike Thompson:

[COMMONWEALTH]: And did you have occasion

to see [defendant] that night?

[THOMPSON]: Yes, ma'am. The first time I

saw him was in Sheriff Woodley's patrol

vehicle going by me. When I saw him in

person face-to-face and spoke to him was at

Brunswick County jail.

[COMMONWEALTH]: All right. And when you

saw [defendant] did he complain of any marks

or any injury?

[THOMPSON]: After I advised him of his

Miranda rights and he invoked his right to

counsel, he requested that Deputy Washburn

take pictures of his injuries.

Defense counsel immediately moved the court for a mistrial,

arguing that mentioning "defendant [had] invoked his right to an

attorney" was "automatic grounds for a mistrial." In denying

the motion, the trial judge commented, "What [Thompson] said was

a prelude to the question about any injury. The Court finds the

statement to be harmless and not prejudicial to the rights.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.