Court of Appeals of Tennessee June 22, 2000, M1999-01039-COA-R3-CV (Fell v. Rambo)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-06-2000

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF TENNESSEE

AT NASHVILLE

MADGE KIRKHAM FELL, ET AL. v. GLORIA RAMBO

Chancery Court for Marshall County

No. 9147 Lee Russell, Judge

No. M1999-01039-COA-R3-CV — Decided June 22, 2000

OPINION DENYING PETITION FOR REHEARING

KOCH , J., delivered the opinion for the court in which CAIN and COTTRELL, JJ., joined.

The remaindermen1 have filed a petition for rehearing in accordance with Tenn. R. App. P.

39 requesting this court to reconsider portions of its May 5, 2000 opinion and order. We directed

Ms. Rambo to respond to the petition and have now received her response. After reviewing our May

5, 2000 opinion and order, we have determined that we neither overlooked nor misconstrued any

material evidence in the appellate record. Accordingly, we adhere to our original May 5, 2000

opinion and order, subject to the typographical correction and the clarifications provided in this

opinion.

I.

We turn first to the remaindermen’s assertion that we “erred by ignoring the effect of Mrs.

Crockett’s will.” They contend we ignored language that they believe reflects Ms. Crockett’s

intention to pass along the proceeds of the sale of the Crockett farm to them. This argument relies

on the following language in Ms. Crockett’s will: “I reiterate and adopt by reference, as if contained

herein verbatim, the language of the Will of my husband, JOHN E. CROCKETT . . . and I devise

and bequeath any such property to which said language is applicable in the same manner therein set

out.”

The trial court pretermitted this argument because Ms. Crockett had sold the farm. The

remaindermen, for their own reasons, did not renew the argument in their original brief or during

oral argument. Thus, we did not address this argument for the simple reason that the remaindermen

did not make it. Even though the remaindermen cannot belatedly raise this argument for the first

1

The remaindermen include: Madge Kirkham Fell, Betty Kirkham Bowland, Bernice

Kirkham Bowers, and Debbie Little.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.