Court of Appeals of Georgia September 13, 2000, A00A1476, A00A1477 (Physician Specialists in Anesthesia, P.C. v. MacNeill)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-09-2000

Mikell, Judge.

The issues in this case revolve around the departure of three physician shareholders from Physician Specialists in Anesthesia, P.C. (“PSA”), a group medical practice specializing in anesthesiology, critical care, and pain management. The three doctors, appellees/ cross-appellants Randy Rizor, Charles A. MacNeill, Jr., and John G. Porter (“Physicians”), filed suit to recover deferred compensation allegedly owed to them pursuant to a Shareholders’ Agreement (“Agreement”) entered into on May 17, 1993, between PSA and its thirteen physician shareholders. PSA defended on the ground that it is entitled to retain the deferred compensation as liquidated damages because the Physicians breached various restrictive covenants when they formed a competing medical practice. PSA also counterclaimed, alleging the Physicians breached their fiduciary duty to PSA, tortiously interfered with PSA’s contractual and business relations, and breached the Agreement’s implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing.

The voluminous record reveals a myriad of disputed and undisputed facts relevant to this appeal. We present them chronologically as follows: Prior to 1990, only Drs. Stanley Mogelnicki and Donn Chambers were shareholders in PSA. All other physicians in PSA, including the plaintiffs, were employees. In 1990, Drs. Mogelnicki and Chambers sold shares of stock to ten physician employees, including the plaintiffs, and the shareholders executed an agreement.

PSA initially held an exclusive contract for the provision of anesthesia services at St. Joseph’s Hospital (“St. Joseph’s”). That contract ended, and in 1992, St. Joseph’s contracted solely with Dr. Mogelnicki’s professional corporation. It does not appear that Dr. Mogelnicki informed the other shareholders of PSA prior to securing the St. Joseph’s contract exclusively for himself.

Dr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.