United States Bankruptcy Court, S.D. Florida. September 13, 2000, 19-12788 (Kozyak v. Asset Base Resources, International, Ltd. (In Re Financial Federated Title & Trust, Inc.))

Also known as

United States · · · 13-09-2000

MEMORANDUM ORDER DENYING DEFENDANT THOMAS D. SCLA-FANFS MOTION TO DISMISS ADVERSARY COMPLAINT

RAYMOND B. RAY, Bankruptcy Judge.

This matter came before the Court for hearing on August 8, 2000 upon the

Motion to Dismiss Adversary Complaint

filed by Defendant Thomas D. Sclafani. The Court, having reviewed the

Motion

and court file, having considered the arguments of counsel, and being otherwise duly advised in the premises, finds as follows.

I. INTRODUCTION

On or about June 15, 2000, Plaintiff John W. Kozyak, Trustee for Financial Federated Title and Trust, Inc. (“FinFed”), the Debtor in the main bankruptcy case from which the instant Adversary Proceeding arises, filed his

Complaint to Avoid Fraudulent Transfers and to Impose Transferee Liability

(the “Complaint”) against Defendants Asset Base Resources International, Ltd. (“ABRI”) and Thomas D. Sclafani, individually (“Sclafani”), seeking to recover alleged fraudulent transfers of over $5 million to ABRI and over $1 million to Sclafani. Sclafani has moved to dismiss the

Complaint

because of the Trustee’s failure to join an entity known as Transcontinental Management Services, Ltd. (“TMS”) which, as will be explained in further detail below, Sclafani claims is an indispensable party under Rule 19 of the

Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

1

For the reasons set forth below, the Court concludes that TMS is not an indispensable party within the meaning of Rule 19 and, accordingly, Sclafani’s

Motion to Dismiss

will be DENIED.

II. BACKGROUND FACTS

Because this matter has come before

the

Court on a

Motion to Dismiss,

all of the allegations contained within the

Complaint

are taken as true. As stated previously, this proceeding involves the avoidance and recovery of certain alleged transfers to the Defendants from FinFed.

According to the

Complaint,

on March 5, 1999, FinFed began a series of transfers totaling over $5 million to an entity known as CSI Ag„ Ltd. (“CSI”).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.