Appellate Court of Illinois January 7, 2000, 4—99—0340, 4—99—0350 cons. (Farmers Automobile Insurance v. Country Mutual Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-01-2000

JUSTICE STEIGMANN

delivered the opinion of the court:

In July 1998, plaintiff, the Farmers Automobile Insurance Association (Farmers), filed an amended complaint for declaratory judgment regarding (1) its duty, if any, to defend Wilfred E. Vance, the decedent of defendant Helen S. Vance, and Wilfred’s son, Dennis Vance, in two tort suits, and (2) the duty of defendant Country Mutual Insurance Company (Country) to defend the Vances in those same two suits. In November 1998, Country filed a counterclaim for declaratory judgment regarding its duty of coverage. Defendants Lloyd T. Eyre (No. 97 — L—6) and Janet F. Lindauer, who appears individually and as special administratrix of the estate of her husband, Robert Lindauer (No. 97 — L—11), are the plaintiffs in the underlying litigation, which involves an automobile collision allegedly caused by Wilfred’s negligence. At the time of the occurrence, Wilfred was driving Dennis’ grain truck in conjunction with Dennis’ farm operation; Farmers provided Wilfred with an automobile liability insurance policy (auto policy), and Country provided Dennis with a farm liability poliqy (farm policy).

In March 1999, the trial court granted summary judgment in Country’s favor, concluding that an exclusion in the farm policy for claims arising out of the ownership or use of a motor vehicle (hereinafter motor vehicle exclusion) applied. Wilfred appeals (No. 4 — 99— 0350), and Farmers appeals separately (No. 4 — 99—0340). Both argue that the court erred in entering summary judgment in Country’s favor. We reverse and remand.

I. BACKGROUND

The allegations of the underlying tort actions are simple. In October 1996, Wilfred was operating Dennis’ 1972 International Loadstar 1600 grain truck on a two-lane public highway, with a trailer full of grain in tow. Wilfred was stopped, waiting to turn off the highway to unload at a grain elevator. Lloyd was driving his car on the same highway and approached Wilfred from behind.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.