Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit March 2, 2000, 99-30040 (Howe v. Scottsdale Insurance Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-03-2000

IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT

No. 99-30040

JOHNNY WADE HOWE,

Individually and on behalf of Courtney Howe,

Plaintiff-Intervenor Defendant-

Appellant

VERSUS

SCOTTSDALE INSURANCE CO.; ET AL.

Defendants

LOUISIANA STATE UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER

Intervenor Plaintiff-Appellee

Appeal from the United States District Court

for the Western District of Louisiana

March 2, 2000

Before HIGGINBOTHAM and SMITH, Judge.*

Circuit Judges, and FALLON, District

1

ELDON E. FALLON, District Judge: On September 22, 1998, LSUMC moved

to intervene in Howe's suit because it

Johnny Wade Howe, on behalf of himself claimed an interest in the proceeds. The

and his daughter Courtney Howe (hereinafter district court granted the motion, and

collectively referred to as "Howe"), sued the LSUMC filed a complaint of intervention on

Louisiana State University Medical Center September 29, 1998 asserting its medical lien

("LSUMC") for a portion of their legal fees privilege over the deposited funds for the

and costs of recovering damages from the amount of Howe's medical bills.

defendants, Scottsdale Insurance Company On October 8, 1998, LSUMC filed a

("Scottsdale"), General Motors Corporation, motion for summary judgment seeking

and Gordon Ira Schlafman. LSUMC, which $22,035.49, the full amount of its medical

treated Howe for injuries suffered in an lien, without any pro-rata reduction for the

automobile accident with Mr. Schlafman, attorney's fees and costs incurred by the

argues that it is entitled to a full plaintiff. Howe opposed the motion arguing

reimbursement from any damage award for that LSUMC, as partial subrogee and/or co-

the services it rendered without any owner, is responsible for its share of the

reduction for a proportionate share of expenses incurred in securing damages from

Howe's legal fees and costs. Because the the defendants.

district court correctly granted summary On December 7, 1998, the district court

judgment for LSUMC, we affirm.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.