New York Court of Appeals November 30, 2000 (Levin v. Intercontinental Casualty Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-11-2000

OPINION OF THE COURT

Rosenblatt, J.

Insurance Law § 1213 (c) requires an “unauthorized foreign or alien” insurance carrier to post a bond before filing “any pleading” in a proceeding against it. In the case at hand, the carrier, after being sued in Supreme Court, did not interpose an answer but instead moved to dismiss the complaint as time barred and subject to a defense founded upon documentary evidence. Does the carrier’s motion constitute a “pleading” within the meaning of section 1213 (c) so as to require it to post a bond? We hold yes.

In 1980, defendant Intercontinental Casualty Insurance Company, a Cayman Islands insurance carrier, and Ideal Mutual Insurance Company, a New York insurance carrier, entered into a Quota Share Reinsurance Agreement to reinsure certain workers’ compensation and employers’ liability policies

*526

of Ideal and one of its subsidiaries. Ideal later became insolvent and the New York State Superintendent of Insurance brought a proceeding in Supreme Court to have Ideal placed in liquidation pursuant to article 74 of the Insurance Law. Supreme Court granted the petition, appointed the Superintendent as liquidator, and vested the Superintendent with title to all of Ideal’s property and rights of action.

In February 1998, the Superintendent, as liquidator, commenced an action in Supreme Court against Intercontinental. On behalf of Ideal’s estate, the Superintendent sought to recover some $20.5 million in reinsurance proceeds allegedly outstanding under the Quota Share Reinsurance Agreement. Interposing no answer, Intercontinental moved to dismiss the complaint on Statute of Limitations and documentary evidence grounds (see, CPLR 3211 [a] [1], [5]). Intercontinental also informed the court that it would not object if the court were to treat the motion as one for summary judgment pursuant to CPLR 3211 (c).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.