District Court, N.D. Illinois August 29, 2000, 96 C 4356 (Hexagon Packaging Corp. v. Manny Gutterman & Associates, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-08-2000
MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER
LEINENWEBER, District Judge.
INTRODUCTION
Before the court are two motions for summary judgment. One has been presented by Manny Gutterman
&
Associates, Inc., in its own name and doing business as M. Gutterman & Associates, Inc./Jelmar; Jelmar; Jamie Industries, Inc.; and Arthur Gutterman (“Gutterman”), individually (collectively, the “Gutterman defendants”). The second motion was filed by defendant Joseph Ruth (“Ruth”).
The Gutterman defendants and Ruth have adopted each other’s motions. Blidco Incorporated, Betty Day Company, Inc., the Estate of Betty Day, Louis C. Day, Jr. and Margaret Renfroe, as personal representatives of the Estate of Betty Day (the “Day Defendants”), have adopted both motions for summary judgment.
BACKGROUND
The parties dispute almost every fact in this case and spin wildly different tales. The facts below are as set forth by Hexagon. The facts that are not disputed by the Gutterman defendants are specifically noted.
See Spolnik v. Guardian Life Insurance Co.,
94 F.Supp.2d 998, 1000 (S.D.Ind.2000) (“The following facts are supported by proper citations to admissible evidence and are taken in the light most favorable to the Plaintiff, the non-moving party on the summary judgment
*714
motion, with all reasonable inferences based on the facts drawn in his favor.”)'
The Origin of Tarn-X and CLR
In 1964, Robert Edison founded the Hosiery Mate Company. Hosiery Mate developed and manufactured various chemical formulations for household and industrial cleaners and disinfectants. In 1967, A1 Eicoff (“Eicoff’) of the A. Eicoff & Co. advertising agency asked Dr. Sylvan Edison and his son Robert (“Edison”) to develop a formula for tarnish remover. The resulting compound became known as “Tarn-X.”
The Edisons and Eicoff agreed that the formula would be owned by Hosiery Mate and that Eicoff and his partners, Manny, Arthur and Steven Gutterman would be responsible for advertising and distributing Tarn-X.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit