District Court, N.D. Indiana August 30, 2000, 1:00-cv-00230 (Fain v. FSC Securities Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-08-2000

ORDER

WILLIAM C. LEE, Chief Judge.

Currently before the Court is Plaintiff Mr. Donald Fain’s Motion to Remand, filed on June 22, 2000. The defendants filed their response on July 11, 2000, to which Mr. Fain replied on July 31, 2000. On August 15, 2000, United States Magistrate Judge Roger Cosbey granted defendant’s Motion to File an Additional Response Brief. Defendants filed their additional response brief that same day. Mr. Fain filed an additional reply brief on August 16, 2000. For the following reasons, the Court will GRANT Mr. Fain’s Motion to Remand.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

Defendant Mr. David Watercutter is an investment advisor doing business as Wat-ercutter Financial Consultants (WFC). Mr. Watercutter provides investment services as an agent of FSC Securities Corporation (FSC). In mid-1999, Hercules Machinery Corporation (Hercules) amended and updated its employee profit-sharing plan, a plan funded solely by employer contributions. According to the plan, only the trustee can choose the investment alternatives for the employees. The employees then choose one or more of these alternatives for their funds. Hercules offered Mr. Watercutter the opportunity to assist its employees by providing investment advice to them with respect to Hercules’ profit-sharing plan. Watercutter, WFC, and FSC are not fiduciaries or plan entities with respect to the Hercules’ plan, however. Rather, the defendants’ only role is that after participants in the Hercules’ plan cashed-out their investments in Hercules’ prior plan, the participants reinvested that money based upon Watercut-ter’s advice regarding investment options.

Mr. Fain is an owner of Hercules and thus a participant in Hercules’ profit-sharing plan. As a participant in the plan, Mr. Fain met with Mr. Watercutter for investment advice, informing Mr. Watercutter of his dissatisfaction with the Hercules’ plan and that he wished to re-invest approximately $260,924.36 in a fund with more risk and a higher profit potential. Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.