District Court, E.D. New York May 1, 2000, 99 CV 7392 (Falise v. American Tobacco Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-05-2000

MEMORANDUM and ORDER

WEINSTEIN, Senior District Judge.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

I INTRODUCTION..321

II FACTS. 323

A. Asbestos. 323

1. Uses and Production.323

2. Exposure.323

3. Health Hazards.324

4. Industry Coverup.324

5. Litigation and Settlement.'..325

B. Tobacco .326

1. Smoking.326

2. Synergy.327

3. Conspiracy.328

a. Synergy Knowledge.328

b. Synergy Coverup.■.328

c. Broader Tobacco Conspiracy.329

d. Tobacco’s Enterprises.332

III SUMMARY JUDGMENT STANDARD.333

IV SECTION 1962(c)-RELATED CLAIMS.333

A. Causation.333

1. Factual Causation: Reliance.333

a. Reliance Showing.335

b. Application to RICO Settlement and Litigation Actions.335

c. Application to RICO Direct Payment Action .337

2. Proximate Causation: Remoteness .338

a. Incorporation of Proximate Causation into Civil RICO.338

b. Holmes.339

c. Laborers Local 17.340

d. Application to RICO Direct Payment Action .342

i. Indirectness and Intervening Forces.342

*321

ii. Duplicative Recovery and Complex Damage Apportionment Co

iii. Ability of More Direct Victims to Remedy Violation. co ^ CR

iv. Specific Intent. co ^ <3^

B.Statute of Limitations. co -J

V SECTION 1962(a)-RELATED CLAIM .348

A. ”Re-investment” Injury .348 B. Other Investment Injuries .349

1. Maintenance of Public Relations Machine.350

2. Maintenance of Litigation Machine.350

a. Noerr-Pennington Doctrine.350

b. Application of Noerr-Pennington Principles.351

VI SECTION 1962(d) -RELATED CLAIMS.353

VIISTATE FRAUD ACTION.’.353

A. Choice of Law.353

B. Fraud.354

C. Statute of Limitations.355

D. Certification.356

VIII PREEMPTION .356

IX CONCLUSION.357

I INTRODUCTION

Defendants have moved for summary judgment. For the reasons indicated below, the cause will be tried.

In recent years, each branch of the federal government has addressed the sweeping allegations of the massive, sustained, and unprecedented fraud of the tobacco companies and their related entities (Tobacco) against the American public.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.