Appellate Court of Illinois May 15, 2000, 4-99-0752 (Schuler v. Mid-Central Cardiology)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-2000

15 May 2000 NO. 4-99-0752 IN THE APPELLATE COURT OF ILLINOIS FOURTH DISTRICT CAROLYN SCHULER, as Administratrix of ) Appeal from the Estate of RICHARD SCHULER, ) Circuit Court of Deceased, ) McLean County Plaintiff-Appellant, ) No. 97L28 v. ) MID-CENTRAL CARDIOLOGY, a Professional ) Corporation, and PATRICK B. MURPHY, ) M.D., ) Defendants-Appellees, ) and ) Honorable ROBERT McENTYRE, M.D., ) Luther H. Dearborn, Defendant. ) Judge Presiding. _________________________________________________________________ PRESIDING JUSTICE COOK delivered the opinion of the court: Carolyn Schuler (plaintiff) appeals a jury verdict in favor of Patrick Murphy, M.D. (Dr. Murphy), and his professional corporation, Mid-Central Cardiology (collectively referred to as defendants). Plaintiff brought this medical malpractice action after the death of her husband, Richard Schuler (Schuler). Schuler died as a result of heart vessel blockage, which occurred during "stress test" procedures being performed by Dr. Murphy. Plaintiff asserts that the circuit court committed a variety of evidentiary errors that prejudiced her case and justify reversal. We affirm the judgment in favor of defendants. I. BACKGROUND On the evening of February 3, 1995, Schuler went to BroMenn Regional Medical Center complaining that he had been experiencing chest pains for two days. Robert McEntyre, M.D. (Dr. McEntyre), an emergency room (ER) physician, attended to Schuler and ordered a battery of tests. Schuler's electrocardio gram (EKG) came back abnormal, but his lab results were within normal limits. Dr. McEntyre decided to obtain a telephone consultation with a cardiologist, Dr. Murphy. The doctors agreed that Schuler's condition was stable and that a follow-up EKG should be performed. Dr. Murphy instructed Dr. McEntyre to call him again after the second EKG. The results of Schuler's second EKG showed improvement but were still abnormal. Dr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.