Missouri Court of Appeals March 7, 2000, No. WD 57054 (Rinne v. Director of Revenue)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-03-2000

HAROLD L. LOWENSTEIN, Judge.

The Director of Revenue (Director) appeals from the order of the circuit court reinstating the driver’s license of the respondent, Kenneth 0. Rinne (Rinne), after it was administratively suspended for driving while intoxicated (DWI) pursuant to § 302.505, RSMo Cum. Supp, 1996. On appeal, the Director claims that the trial court erred in sustaining the respondent’s motion to dismiss for lack of probable cause because the admissible evidence was insufficient to establish the requisite probable cause for the arrest.

The judgment is reversed.

FACTS

In December 1997, Laurie police officer Jim Walker responded to a call notifying him of a wreck on County Road 0 in Morgan County. Officer Walker arrived at the scene and discovered that Rinne’s truck had run off the left shoulder of the road and hit a tree fifty feet from the roadway. Officer Walker found Rinne in the driver’s seat attempting to restart the totaled car. Rinne was hurt, mumbling and bleeding from the head. Officer Walker noticed a “moderate odor of intoxicants” emanating from Rinne.

Trooper William Surface of the Missouri Highway Patrol arrived thirty minutes after Officer Walker. Officer Walker conveyed to Trooper Surface that he believed Rinne was intoxicated. Rinne’s injuries prevented field sobriety tests. Trooper Surface interviewed Rinne in the ambulance, asking him what had happened, and Rinne responded, “Nothing.” Surface then asked if he had been driving alone and Rinne responded, “Yes.” Finally, the trooper asked Rinne whether he had been drinking. Rinne replied that he had consumed “three beers.” Trooper Surface also noticed a moderate odor of intoxicants on Rinne’s breath and that he had watery eyes. Trooper Surface then arrested him for driving while intoxicated and asked Rinne to consent to a blood test at the hospital. Rinne agreed.

Section 302.505, RSMo Cum.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.