California Court of Appeal October 12, 2000, No. G018844 (O'Keefe v. Kompa)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-10-2000

Opinion

CROSBY, J.

Plaintiff Thomas J. O’Keefe sued defendants for abuse of process and title disparagement after defendants initiated collection efforts on a judgment on appeal. That judgment was against O’Keefe personally and arose out of an earlier action he brought for attorney fees under Civil Code section 1717. The superior court sustained defendants’ demurrers without leave to amend, reasoning an undertaking was required under Code of Civil Procedure sections 916 and 917.1 to stay collection efforts pending appeal. For the reasons set forth below, we affirm.

I

In the underlying litigation, O’Keefe sought to recover $30,000 he was forced to pay as guarantor on a loan to a failed business entity. He also sought attorney fees based on a fee-shifting provision in the loan documents. Not only did O’Keefe lose that case, but also he was ordered to pay just over $50,000 for defendants’ attorney fees under Civil Code section 1717. O’Keefe appealed the judgment, including the attorney fees order, but posted no bond or undertaking (believing none was required). We subsequently affirmed.1

While that appeal was pending, however, attorneys for the two subsets of the present defendants took steps to secure payment of the attorney fees judgment. That is, Attorney Donald Studer, representing several individual defendants in the underlying action, levied on a bank account of O’Keefe’s law partnership, while Attorney Mark A. Kompa, who represented the balance of the defendants, filed an abstract of judgment with the Orange County Recorder’s Office.

O’Keefe was not amused. Several months later he sued Attorney Kompa and his clients, as well as Studer, for abuse of process and slander of title.2 The gist of plaintiff’s complaint was that his appeal of the underlying judgment and attorney fees order automatically stayed any collection efforts *133under Code of Civil Procedure sections 916 and 917.1.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.