New York Supreme Court September 14, 2000 (People v. Owens)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-09-2000

*642OPINION OF THE COURT

David D. Egan, J.

This is a death penalty case. Jury selection commenced on September 6, 2000.

Defendant seeks an unspecified increase in the daily compensation for prospective jurors selected potentially to serve on this trial. Defendant also seeks to accommodate jurors with children by providing child-care facilities and adjourning daily at 2:30 p.m. or 3:00 p.m.

Defendant claims that if these measures are not adopted, prospective jurors from lower economic classes (a disproportionate share of whom are minorities) will be discouraged from serving as jurors at trial and, thus, undermine his right to a trial by a jury composed from a fair cross section of the community.

Judiciary Law § 521 mandates jury compensation rates. Effective February 15, 1998 the daily allowance for a juror, with certain exceptions, was increased from $15 to $40. (Id.) This Court is not inclined to alter the compensation rate set by statute. Further, the development of child-care facilities comes under the auspices of the Office of Court Administration, and not this Court. (22 NYCRR 34.0.)* While there is a Children’s Center located in the Hall of Justice where this Court holds its proceedings, that center is not a licensed full-time day-care center, but a drop-in facility designed for child litigants or the children of litigants, involved primarily in Family Court proceedings. This Court is without authority to mandate the development of full-time licensed day-care facilities simply to accommodate the jurors in this case. (Cf. People v Francios, Dutchess County Ct, June 14, 1999, Dolan, J., slip opn, at 2; People v Page, Kings County Ct, Sept. 8, 1998, Hall, J., slip opn, at 1-2.) Defendant’s request for such relief therefore is also denied.

Defendant also asks that during the trial (except jury deliberations) the Court adjourn each day between 2:30 p.m. and 3:00 p.m. to accommodate those jurors with school-age children. The defendant’s argument is counterintuitive.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.