Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Alleghany County February 7, 2000, G.D. no. 98-14720 (Graham v. Laidlaw Transit Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-02-2000

STRASSBURGER, J.

— On September 16,1998, plaintiffs filed a complaint in Allegheny County seeking damages arising from an accident involving a school bus, owned by the defendant and operated by one of defendant’s employees, and a pickup track operated by Jacob Charles Graham. On January 18, 2000, defendant filed its petition to transfer venue under forum non conveniens, requesting that venue be transferred from Allegheny County to Erie County.

*495The accident occurred in Erie County when the operator of a school bus was returning to the Laidlaw bus terminal in Erie County after completing her job of transporting school students in the Northwest School District in Erie County. The operator of the school bus is a resident of Erie County. Jacob Graham, who was also an Erie County resident, suffered death from injuries received in the accident. The rescue personnel at the scene of the accident were from the Cranesville Fire Department in Erie County. Decedent received medical treatment at Hamot Medical Center in Erie County. The accident was investigated by the Pennsylvania State Police from the Girard barracks in Erie County. Defendant’s representatives, who went to the scene of the accident, worked out of defendant’s terminal in Erie County. The only eyewitnesses to the accident are residents of Crawford County which, being adjacent to Erie County, is closer to Erie County than it is to Allegheny County.

All of the plaintiffs reside in Erie County. The co-administrators of decedent’s estate were appointed by an Erie County court.

The only connection of this case to Allegheny County is that the defendant, a Canadian corporation, has an office in Allegheny County. This address is listed on the school bus registration. Defendant’s business as relevant to this case, however, is the operation of school buses in the Northwest School District of Erie County.

Procedurally, on February 15,2000, this case is scheduled for an argument on defendant’s motion for summary judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.