Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Alleghany County May 15, 2000, no. GD 99-13642 (Spisak v. Edelstein)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-2000

FRIEDMAN, J.,

Plaintiff has appealed this court’s order dated January 31, 2000, in which we sustained defendant law firm’s preliminary objections and dismissed plaintiff’s complaint with prejudice. The court’s decision to dismiss the complaint was based on estoppel principles, arising from the fact that the allegations of the instant complaint reveal that plaintiff had a full opportunity to raise the instant matters complained of in the prior action and that the prior action was the only appropriate place to raise them. In his statement of matters complained of on appeal, plaintiff contends that his failure to raise the defendant’s alleged misconduct in the prior case before the judges involved there does not constitute waiver. The allegations of the complaint involve defendant’s conduct in another case as counsel for a third party, and are briefly summarized below.

Instant plaintiff, Mr. Spisalt, had sued Penn National Insurance Company in a previous action, now finally decided. Instant defendant, Margolis Edelstein, is the law firm which represented Penn National in that litigation *367through one of its partners, Arthur Bloom.1 According to plaintiff’s complaint, the previous case involved an insurance bad faith action and resulted in a verdict in favor of Mr. Spisak “in the amount of $750,000 in punitive damages and $62,400 in interest.” Plaintiff also alleges that Mr. Bloom was untruthful and made false statements [as counsel for Penn National in the previous case] as follows:

“(A) In improperly redacting produced documents contrary to the order of court of October 23, 1998 [entered by Judge Wettick in the previous case].

“(B) In his undated affidavit [submitted pursuant to the direction of Judge Wettick in the previous case] when he alleged the documents were redacted in compliance with the order of court of October 23, 1998.

“(C) In his representations to Judge Johnson that Mr. McKenna told him (Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.