Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court August 30, 2000 (Bates v. Superior Court)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-08-2000
The plaintiff, Thomas Bates, appeals from an order of a single justice of this court dismissing his complaint for declaratory relief. The single justice was correct to deny the requested relief.
We shall accept as true the facts alleged in the plaintiff’s complaint, which are as follows. The plaintiff is a Massachusetts inmate. Prior to his conviction and incarceration he resided in Worcester County. At some point during his incarceration, he filed a complaint and thereby commenced a civil action in the Superior Court in Worcester County.1 The plaintiff was incarcerated in *1022Plymouth County when he filed that complaint. A judge in the Superior Court dismissed the complaint for lack of venue.2
Thomas Bates, pro se.
Steven E. Thomas, Assistant Attorney General, for the defendant.
The plaintiff subsequently filed his complaint in the county court seeking a declaration as to “(a) the criteria for determining the domicil or residency for the purpose of filing civil actions in the Superior Court[; and] (b) whether [he] meets those criteria.” The sole defendant named in this action was the Superior Court judge who had previously dismissed the plaintiff’s action in Worcester County. The single justice dismissed the plaintiff’s complaint, and the plaintiff appealed.
We agree with the single justice’s determination that the declaratory relief sought by the plaintiff was unwarranted in the circumstances.3 The plaintiff could have obtained the type of relief he sought by appealing from the dismissal of his Superior Court action.4 The single justice properly concluded that the plaintiff could not, in lieu of pursuing his available appellate remedy, obtain a declaration under G. L. c. 231A by recasting the issue in terms of a personal dispute with the Superior Court judge. See Hathaway v. Commissioner of Ins., 379 Mass. 551, 553 (1980) (“It is ordinarily not appropriate to grant declaratory relief to a party which has ignored its statutory right of direct review”). Cf.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit