United States Court of Federal Claims December 5, 2000, No. 98-761 C (Orient Overseas Container Line (UK) Ltd. v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-12-2000

OPINION AND ORDER

HEWITT, Judge.

This is a suit by a common carrier for reimbursement of costs associated with the detention of illegal stowaways. Plaintiff, Orient Overseas Container Line (UK) Ltd., con*286tends that it is entitled to reimbursement of its expenses incurred in connection with the stowaways, including attorneys’ fees expended in connection with an arbitration hearing between plaintiff and Sea-Land Service Inc. (Sea-Land), its shipper, and interest on the sum paid by plaintiff to Sea-Land. The United States, acting through the Immigration and Naturalization Service (defendant or the INS), concedes liability as to certain costs, including the costs of detention, but argues that it is not liable for deportation costs, attorneys’ fees or prejudgment interest. The action is before the court on defendant’s motion for partial summary judgment, addressing solely attorneys’ fees and prejudgment interest, and plaintiffs cross-motion for summary judgment on all issues. For the following reasons, Defendant’s Motion is GRANTED with respect to attorneys’ fees and interest, and Plaintiffs Motion is GRANTED with respect to all other costs demanded in the complaint.

I. Background

Plaintiff entered into an agreement with Sea-Land, effective February 1, 1993. Amended Joint Statement of Stipulated Facts (AJSSF) H1. Under the agreement, Sea-Land agreed to ship plaintiffs containers between various ports in Europe and the United States. Id. II2; Plaintiffs Cross Motion for Summary Judgment (Pl.’s Mot.), Exh. A, at 3-4. The agreement provided that each party would issue its own bills of lading, and that plaintiff would be responsible for “costs attributable to cargo” for which it issued a bill of lading. AJSSF $ 2; Amended Complaint filed September 28, 2000 (Am. Compl.) H 41; Pl.’s Mot., Exh. A, at 9-10. The agreement also provided that any dispute arising under it would be referred to arbitration in London. Pl.’s Mot., Exh. A, at 22.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.