Supreme Court of Vermont October 16, 2000, No. 99-443 (Darden v. O'Keefe)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-10-2000
Defendant Steven O’Keefe appeals from a summary judgment in favor of plaintiff Lisa Darden on her judgment lien foreclosure complaint, claiming the court erred in: (1) deciding defendant’s property was not entitled to homestead protection; and (2) shortening the redemption period without notice to him. He challenges the authority of the trial court to condition his right of appeal on giving a bond. We agree that the trial court could condition his appeal on providing a bond and dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction.
Plaintiff filed her judgment lien foreclosure complaint against defendant on July 17, 1998, based on a judgment she obtained against him in 1992. The underlying debt involves defendant’s failure to pay on a promissory note he gave to plaintiff to purchase land on which he has built a house over a period of fifteen years. Defendant resisted the judgment lien foreclosure action by claiming that the land and house is a homestead, exempt from enforcement of the judgment lien by 27 VS.A. § 101. See Mercier v. Partlow, 149 Vt. 523, 527, 546 A.2d 787, 790 (1988) (homestead exemption applies in action to enforce judgment lien). The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment on the issue, and the trial court granted plaintiff’s motion, ruling that homestead protection did not apply on the facts of the case. Defendant both filed a notice of appeal and moved for permission to appeal, arguing, however, that permission was unnecessary. The superior court ruled that permission was necessary and granted it, conditional on defendant posting a $50,000 bond to provide security for plaintiff’s prospective losses. Defendant failed to post the bond, arguing instead that no permission was necessary, and plaintiff moved to dismiss the appeal because of defendant’s failure to comply with the appeal condition.
The issue of whether permission to appeal is required in this case turns on the proper interpretation of 12 VS.A.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit