Massachusetts Superior Court February 14, 2000, No. 963746 (Kristi's Restaurant Group, Inc. v. Zussman)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-02-2000
Botsford, J.
This case has had three separate phases, each of which has been tried. This phase concerns Chapter 93A claims of the plaintiff, Kristi’s Restaurant Group, Inc. (Kristi’s), and it was tried before me on November 19,1999.2 My findings of fact are set out first, followed by a discussion of legal issues. I conclude that Kristi’s has proved that the defendant, David Zussman, trustee of the Union Realty Trust (Zussman) violated G.L.c. 93A, §§2 and 11, as set forth in Counts V and VI of the third amended complaint, and is entitled to recover reasonable associated attorneys fees and costs from Zussman.
Findings of Fact3
The relationship between Kristi’s and Zussman has been anything but amicable. Although the April 13, 1995 lease agreement (April 13 agreement) was supposed to have resolved all the simmering disputes between tenant and landlord, paving the way for a new beginning, within a few days after the agreement was signed, Zussman accused Kristi’s of violating the agreement by placing a second walk-in refrigerator in the rear of the restaurant and constructing a shed-like structure over both refrigerator units. The battle lines were drawn once again.
The April 13 agreement provided that on April 14, 1995, Kristi’s was to pay Zussman the $13,983.86 which Kristi’s had earlier withheld in rent payments, and Zussman was to dismiss the pending summary process action on the same date. On April 14, Kristi’s paid the prescribed amount to Zussman. Zussman did not dismiss the summary process case.
As set out in the memorandum of decision dated April 28, 1999, by May of 1995, Zussman took the position that the April 13 agreement was void on account of Kristi’s purported violations.4 Zussman, however, did not return the $13,983.86 which Kristi’s had paid pursuant to the agreement’s terms. In addition, when Kristi’s paid its monthly rent for May 1995 to Zussman in the higher amount called for by the April 13 agreement — $9,000.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit