Massachusetts Superior Court October 12, 2000, No. WOCV9501772A (Brown v. Commonwealth)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-10-2000

Donohue, J.

On March 24, 1984, petitioner Edward' Brown entered a plea of guilty to multiple counts of Soliciting a Child to Pose for Pornographic Purposes and Rape of a Child. On May 14, 1984, Justice Travers found petitioner to be a “sexually dangerous person” pursuant to G.L.c. 123A and committed him, in lieu of a criminal sentence, to the Massachusetts Treatment Center for a term of not less than one day and not more than his natural life.

Brown now brings this pro se petition for habeas corpus challenging his confinement to the Treatment Center. Petitioner asserts numerous arguments in support of his challenge. Respondent seeks dismissal of the suit. For the reasons stated below, respondent’s motion to dismiss is ALLOWED.

DISCUSSION

After a thorough review of petitioner’s affidavit and memorandum of law, the court determines that petitioner raises the following claims:

1. EQUAL PROTECTION

Petitioner first argues that a 1990 amendment to G.L.c. 123A, which closed the treatment center to new commitments, violates the equal protection clause of the United States Constitution. Petitioner claims that the amendment unconstitutionally creates two classes of prisoners who committed sex crimes — one subject to an indefinite term in the center who must file for a hearing and prove they are no longer sexually dangerous to be released and the other serving definite sentences. In Commonwealth v. Tate, 424 Mass. 236 (1997), the Supreme Judicial Court rejected the identical argument finding that ”[e]qual protection principles do not bar the continuation of the treatment program for persons already in it just because the *427Legislature terminated future commitments.” Id. at 241. Thus, petitioner’s claim is without merit.

Petitioner next argues that G.L.c. 123A violates the equal protection clause because it treats male and female sex offenders differently. Petitioner contends that G.L.c. 123A is only enforced against male sex offenders.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.