District Court, M.D. Florida May 4, 2000, No. 699CV552-0RL-18A (Pezold Air Charters v. Phoenix Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-05-2000

ORDER

G. KENDALL SHARP, Senior District Judge.

Pezold Air Charters (PAC) sues Phoenix Corporation for breach of a contract to upgrade PAC’s Beechcraft King Air aircraft with new engines. Phoenix countersues against PAC and its owner, Jack Pezold, claiming that they, together with several others, conspired (1) to misrepresent the status of Phoenix’s upgrade plan to the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) so that the FAA would revoke Phoenix’s authority to perform upgrades, (2) to use Phoenix’s trade secrets to create a new competing method for performing upgrades, and (3) to undermine Phoenix’s business by publishing false and misleading information on the internet about the Phoenix upgrade plan and Phoenix’s principals.

Several motions are presently before the Court including, among others, Phoenix’s motion to dismiss PAC’s claims (Doc. 132); PAC and Mr. Pezold’s motion for summary judgment on Phoenix’s counterclaims (Doc. 33); and Phoenix’s motion to voluntarily dismiss its counterclaims (Doc. 133). After reviewing the record and the applicable law, the Court finds that PAC’s claims should not be dismissed but that Phoenix’s counterclaims cannot survive summary judgment.

I. Background

A The Parties

Jack Pezold owned an air chartering business known as Pezold Air Charters, L.L.C. (PAC). (See Dep. Pezold at 9, Doc. 37.) Phoenix Corporation was in the business of designing and installing aircraft engine conversion modifications to improve the performance of older aircraft.. (See Decl. Bailey ¶¶ 10-11, Doc. 104.) In particular, William Gordon Bailey, a principal of Phoenix, helped Phoenix develop a plan for upgrading older Beechcraft King Air airplanes by replacing the aircraft’s Pratt & Whitney PT6 engines *723with modern Walter 601E-11 turboprop engines. (See id. ¶¶ 6-10.) On May 16, 1997, the FAA approved the plan by issuing to Phoenix Supplemental Type Certificate SA013366AT (Phoenix STC). (See id. ¶10.)

B. The Agreement with Phoenix

In early August 1997, Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.