Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Erie County July 14, 2000, no. 14121-1998 (Nationwide Mutual Insurance v. Catalfu)

CUNNINGHAM, P. J,

The issue before the court is whether Debbie Jo Catalfu can collect underinsured benefits from an automobile policy issued by the plaintiff, Nationwide, to Ms. Catalfu’s father, Richard Catalfu. Nationwide seeks enforcement of a “household” or “family car” exclusion barring recovery. In response, Ms.