Court of Appeals of Tennessee July 13, 2001, E2001-00007-COA-R3-CV (Donald Miller v. Choo Choo Partners)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-07-2001

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF TENNESSEE

AT KNOXVILLE

July 13, 2001 Session

DONALD MILLER, ET AL. v. CHOO CHOO PARTNERS, L. P.

Appeal from the Circuit Court for Hamilton County

No. 99CV0720 Samuel H. Payne, Judge

FILED NOVEMBER 5, 2001

No. E2001-00007-COA-R3-CV

D. MICHAEL SWINEY, J., dissenting

I find it necessary to dissent, respectfully, from the majority opinion. I believe the

Trial Court erred in failing to direct a verdict in Defendant’s favor based upon Plaintiffs’ failure to

present medical evidence that Mr. Miller’s back and neck injuries were more likely than not caused

by his fall. I believe the medical testimony presented by Plaintiffs fails to satisfy this burden, even

taking the strongest legitimate view of the evidence in favor of Plaintiffs as we must.

As discussed in the majority opinion, Plaintiffs presented medical evidence by the

testimony of Mr. Miller’s two treating physicians. It is this testimony that is the crux of my dissent.

I have no disagreement with the law as discussed in the majority opinion. I agree with

the majority as to what the law is, but disagree as to whether or not Plaintiffs met their burden as

required by law. As discussed by the majority, the causation of a medical condition must be

established by testimony from a medical expert. Thomas v. Aetna Life & Cas. Co., 812 S.W.2d 278,

283 (Tenn. 1991). I rely upon the same Tennessee Supreme Court case, and in fact the same

language, as the majority, as follows:

“The plaintiff must introduce evidence which affords a reasonable basis for the

conclusion that it is more likely than not that the conduct of the defendant was a

cause in fact of the result. A mere possibility of such causation is not enough; and

when the matter remains one of pure speculation or conjecture or the probabilities are

at best evenly balanced, it becomes the duty of the court to direct a verdict for the

defendant …

The plaintiff is not, however, required to prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.