New York Court of Appeals December 13, 2001 (MacChirole v. Giamboi)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-12-2001

OPINION OF THE COURT

Ciparick, J.

Plaintiff Anthony Macchirole was a union fireproofer and an employee of Giamboi Brothers, Inc. (“GBI”), a closely-held family corporation engaged in the fireproofing and plastering business. Plaintiff typically performed fireproofing work for GBI. Defendant Joseph Giamboi was the Chairman of the Board and a principal shareholder of GBI. In the spring of 1995, a GBI foreman requested at defendant’s direction that plaintiff and another union worker perform maintenance work on defendant’s Garden City home. Plaintiff and a co-worker began work, including painting, cleaning and gardening, at

*149

defendant’s residence. GBI paid plaintiff his standard union wages, with benefits, and plaintiff reported to his GBI superintendent as usual. At all times, plaintiff regarded defendant as his “boss.”

When the assigned maintenance work was completed, defendant requested that plaintiff and his co-worker trim the hedges and trees surrounding the residence. Defendant supplied an electric hedge-trimmer, borrowed from a GBI warehouse, and a ladder to assist the men in their task. While perched on the ladder and trimming a 10-foot tree, plaintiff lost his balance and fell. Before plaintiff struck the ground, the electric trimmer, still operating, clipped and severely lacerated his right hand.

Plaintiff recovered workers’ compensation from the corporation’s insurance carrier. Thereafter he commenced this action against defendant as owner of the residence, alleging negligence and violations of Labor Law §§ 200, 240 and 241.

*

Supreme Court granted defendant’s motion for summary judgment and dismissed the complaint. The court concluded that because plaintiff was an “employee” performing work for his employer at the time of the accident, his exclusive remedy was workers’ compensation.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.