California Court of Appeal August 28, 2001, F034484 (Allied Mutual Insurance v. Webb)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-08-2001
Opinion
LEVY, J.
Appellants, Rick Webb and Mary Leon, challenge the trial court’s finding that a business automobile liability policy issued by respondent, Allied Mutual Insurance Company (Allied), to Dallas Brothers Farms (Dallas Brothers) did not provide coverage for an accident caused by a Dallas Brothers employee. The trial court concluded that, although the subject pickup truck was covered as a “borrowed vehicle,” the employee, Richard Galvan, was not insured as a permissive user. The court further noted that, even if Galvan were a permissive user, his conduct exceeded the scope of the implied permission.
*1192
In order to prevail, appellants must demonstrate that both components of the trial court’s ruling are incorrect as a matter of law. With respect to Galvan’s status as a permissive user of the truck, appellants argue that Dallas Brothers granted such permission by ratifying Galvan’s conduct. According to appellants, this ratification occurred when Dallas Brothers failed to either reprimand or discharge Galvan following the accident. Appellants further contend that the policy insures a permissive user for any conduct because it does not restrict coverage to use that falls within the scope of the permission.
However, a nonpermitted use of a vehicle cannot be ratified by the insured after an accident so as to impose liability on the insurer. Thus, on this ground alone, we affirm. The trial court correctly concluded that there was no coverage under the Allied policy. Consequently, there is no need to decide whether Galvan’s conduct would have exceeded the scope of the permission if permission had been granted.
Statement of the Case and Facts
Robert E. Dallas (Robert, Sr.) and his sons, Robert A. Dallas (Robert, Jr.) and Thomas Dallas, grow and pack sweet potatoes. This family farming operation is conducted through several entities owned in various proportions by these individuals. Robert, Jr.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit