Supreme Judicial Court of Maine May 2, 2001 (Stickney v. City of Saco)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-05-2001

RUDMAN, J.

[¶ 1] Marion Stickney and William Casa-vant Jr.

1

appeal from a judgment entered

*598

in the Superior Court (York County,

Fritz-sche,

/.), that (1) declared Tasker Lane in the City of Saco to be a public way; (2) granted the City of Saco a prescriptive easement in land beyond the paved area of Tasker Lane; and (3) dismissed plaintiffs’ § 1983 claim. William and Tammy Des-Jardins appeal from that portion of the court’s judgment concluding that Casavant has an easement, ten feet in width, on the portion of the DesJardinses’ property at which the parties share a common boundary. We disagree with parties’ contentions and affirm the judgment of the Superior Court.

I. FACTS

&

PROCEDURAL HISTORY

A. The Lane

[¶ 2] This consolidated action involves (1) the determination of the status of Tasker Lane, the narrow road — roughly 100 yards in length — connecting Hill and Lincoln Streets in the City of Saco, and (2) the status of a right-of-way reserved in a 1915 deed across the DesJardinses’ property. Tasker Lane was first established as a “private passageway” to the Homestead Farm of Joseph Hill, the common grantor of all the property at issue. The Hill homestead, which sat on what is now the Casavant property, was destroyed in the 1960s.

[¶ 3] The area in question is essentially triangular in shape, bounded on the northwest by Hill Street, on the south by Lincoln Street (formerly known as the “Boom Road”), and on the east by a strip of land owned by parties not involved in this action. Tasker Lane diagonally severs this area in two. Although the City did not pave the lane until 1985, it had maintained the road for over forty years. The Fitan-ides family helped to plow the lane since the 1940s. Within the past 40 years, however, the family’s plowing has been infrequent and undefined in scope. Presently, Tasker Lane is a one-lane, paved road with no sidewalks or curbs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.