District Court, E.D. California September 27, 2001, CV-F-00-6106 REC/LJO (Harlan Land Co. v. U.S. Department of Agriculture)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-09-2001

ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT, DENYING DEFENDANTS’ MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT, SUSPENDING ARGENTINE CITRUS RULE AND REMANDING TO APHIS (Docs. 31

&

36)

COYLE, District Judge.

On May 21, 2001, the court heard the parties’ Cross Motion for Summary Judgment.

Upon due consideration of the oral and written arguments and the record herein, plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment is granted and defendants’ motion for summary judgment is denied for the reasons set forth herein.

I.

Factual Background

In 1993, Argentina officially requested Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (“APHIS”), a division of United States Department of Agriculture, to amend its regulations so that lemons, oranges and grapefruit grown in the Argentine States of Catamarca, Jujuy, Salta, and Tucuman could be imported into the United States. Statement of Stipulated Facts, ¶ 1. Two citrus pests, citrus black spot and sweet orange scab, that exist in these Argentine States are not present in the United States.

Id.

at ¶ 2. APHIS officials visited the Argentina growing areas in May 1994 and determined that they could not fully assess the risk of citrus black spot and sweet orange scab under the protocol proposed by Argentina. 1994 Trip Report, AR 591. In 1995, APHIS denied Argentina’s petition “unless pest free areas can be established or treatments can be approved” for the two diseases. Decision on Entry Status, AR at 2386. Consequently, at the request of APHIS, Argentina conducted research and surveys and submitted reports on the research to APHIS in support of its petition. Statement of Stipulated Facts, ¶ 3.

In September 1997, APHIS prepared a Supplemental Plant Pest Risk Assessment (“Risk Assessment”) to evaluate the likelihood that plant pests and citrus diseases from Argentina would be introduced into the United States if commercial shipments of Argentine citrus to the United States were allowed.

Id.

at ¶4, AR at 1-110.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.