District Court, S.D. New York February 20, 2001, 99 Civ. 1171(LLS) (AB Recur Finans v. Nordstern Insurance Co. of North America)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-02-2001

OPINION and ORDER

STANTON, District Judge.

Plaintiff AB Recur Finans (“ABRF”), a Swedish corporation and finance company, brings this action against defendant AXA Nordstern Art Insurance Corporation of North America, a New York corporation (successor to named defendant Nordstern Insurance Company of North America)

*598

(“Nordstern”) for payment, up to Nordst-ern’s million dollar policy limit, of a judgment entered in ABRF’s favor against Nordstern’s insured, Judson Art Warehouse, Inc. (“Judson”).

Nordstern seeks summary judgment dismissing the, complaint, and ABRF cross-moves for, summary judgment in its favor. No material facts are in dispute.

Background

1.

Undisputed Facts

1

Judson Art Warehouse, now defunct, operated a warehouse facility where it cat-alogued, stored, shipped and displayed antiques and works of art for private collectors, dealers and others.

Up until 1991, it was covered by successive insurance policies for warehouseman’s legal liability issued by Nordstern (the “Policy”).

In 1989 Lennart Andersson (a Swedish art dealer) bought a Cy Twombly painting from Peder Bonnier by borrowing $2,000,000 from Fortune Finans AB (“Fortune”), the plaintiff ABRF’s predecessor in interest.

When Andersson received title to the painting he granted Fortune a security interest in it. Judson (in whose warehouse the painting was stored for Andersson) signed an agreement (the “Notification Agreement”) in which Judson acknowledged Fortune’s security interest in the painting and agreed not to release the painting to any party, including Anders-son, without Fortune’s prior consent.

Andersson soon defaulted on his loan repayments to Fortune. Bonnier, unpaid, asked Judson to return the painting to him, which it did, unfortunately without informing Fortune or obtaining Fortune’s consent. When Bonnier received the painting, he resold it to a third party.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.