Court of Appeals of Oregon October 3, 2001, 9809-06686; A108482 (Demilly v. Butler Amusements, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-10-2001

*108

WOLLHEIM, J.

Plaintiff filed this personal injury action against defendant, Butler Amusements (Butler), for negligence, negligence

per se,

and violation of the Employer Liability Law, ORS 654.305 to ORS 654.335. The trial court granted Butler’s motion to bifurcate the trial and first held a bench trial on its affirmative defenses. The trial court agreed with Butler’s affirmative defense that plaintiff was a “worker” under the Workers’ Compensation Act and that the Act was plaintiffs exclusive remedy. Accordingly, it dismissed plaintiffs complaint and entered judgment for Butler. Plaintiff appeals from that judgment. We affirm.

In June 1997, plaintiff, his brother, and some friends attended the last night of the Portland Rose Festival Fun Center. They rode the Giant Gondola Wheel just before closing. After the ride ended, they were approached by one of Butler’s employees, the operator of the gondola. The employee asked them if they wanted to help dismantle the ride that night. The employee told them that the employees had set a record the year before in dismantling the ride and that they wanted to break the record that night. The employee also said that they would all “party” together after-wards. Plaintiff and his brother agreed to do the work.

Butler is a traveling carnival with a full-time, year-round office in Beaverton. Butler employs 12 to 13 full-time administrative employees and employs thousands of seasonal employees. It also hires temporary laborers to assist in dismantling the rides. Butler’s typical practice in hiring temporary laborers is to obtain the name, address, and social security number of the temporary laborers on a piece of paper. The laborers are paid minimum wage in cash following the completion of the work.

Plaintiff denies having signed documents or forms. Butler was unable to locate any paper work regarding the laborers who were working for it at the Rose Festival at the time of plaintiff’s accident.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.