Court of Appeals of Washington April 17, 2001, 46666-6-I (Samuel's Furniture v. Department of Ecology)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-04-2001

19 P.3d 474 (2001) SAMUEL'S FURNITURE, INC., Jaffa Holdings, Inc., and City of Ferndale, Respondents, v. WASHINGTON STATE DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY, Appellant. No. 46666-6-I. Court of Appeals of Washington, Division 1. March 12, 2001. As Amended on Denial of Reconsideration April 17, 2001. *475 Thomas Young, Assistant Attorney General, Olympia, for Appellant. Kurt Denke, Seattle, Heather Wolfe, Langabeer, Tull & Lee, P.S., for Respondents. Greg Overstreet, Timothy D. Ford, Counsel for Amicus Curiae Building Industry Association of Washington. COLEMAN, J. The Department of Ecology appeals from summary judgment in a declaratory judgment action initiated by Samuel's Furniture, Inc. Samuel's applied to the City of Ferndale for a grade and fill permit and a building permit in order to begin construction to expand its store. The City issued the permits after it reviewed its jurisdictional maps and determined that the site was outside shoreline jurisdiction. The Department insisted that the City's jurisdictional determination was incorrect and threatened to take enforcement against Samuel's if construction continued. Samuel's asked the Superior Court to decide whether the site is within shoreline jurisdiction. The Superior Court did not reach that issue, but instead, granted summary judgment in favor of Samuel's, holding that the Department was estopped from bringing enforcement action against Samuel's. The central issue before this court is whether the Department is required to appeal the City's threshold jurisdictional determination under Washington's Land Use Petition Act (LUPA) or whether the Department has independent enforcement authority under the Shoreline Management Act (SMA). It has been established in Washington that a local government's threshold determination regarding shoreline jurisdiction is not determinative.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.