District Court, E.D. Washington July 10, 2001, CS-00-0031-JLQ (Kettle Range Conservation Group v. United States Forest Service)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-07-2001
MEMORANDUM ORDER AND OPINION GRANTING IN PART PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND ENJOINING BARK BEETLE PROJECT IN COLVILLE NATIONAL FOREST
QUACKENBUSH, Senior District Judge.
Before the court is Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment (Ct.Rec.59), Defendant-Intervenor Vaagen Brothers Lumber’s Motion for Summary Judgment (Ct. Rec.50), the Motion for Summary Judgment filed by all other Defendants (“the Federal Defendants”) (Ct.Rec.46), and various related motions. The court held a hearing on these motions on June 25, 2001. Plaintiffs were represented by Mark Wilson. The Federal Defendants were represented by William Beatty and Val Black. The Defendant-Intervenor was represented by Robert Maynard and Rocco Trep-piedi.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. Background. 1112
II. Summary Judgment Standard of Review.1113
III. Procedural Challenges.1114
A.
Standing
.1114
B. Exhaustion.1114
C.
Abandonment of
Claims.1114
D.
Scope of the Record
.1114
IV. The Merits of the Summary Judgment Motions .1116
A.
Standard of Review for Administrative
Decisions.1116
B.
Scope of the Statement of Purpose
(Second Claim).1117
C.
The Breadth and Nature of the Alternatives Considered
(Second Claim, Third Claim) .1118
D.
Analysis of Project’s
Effects.1121
1.
Effects of the Project on Specific Environmental
Elements.1121
a.
Fuels and
Fire.1121
b. Vegetation.1122
c. Watershed.1123
d. Fisheries.1123
e. Wildlife. 1124
f. Soils.1125
2.
Cumulative Impacts Analysis
(Seventh, Eighth, and (Ninth Claims).... 1127
E.
The Role of Financing and the Lack of Disclosure
(Fifth Claim).1132
V. The Need For and the Scope of the Injunction .1135
*1112
VI. Conclusion.
I. Background
This case is on remand from the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals for a consideration of the merits of the pending cross-motions for summary judgment.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit