District Court, S.D. New York November 19, 2001, 99 CIV. 1828(RWS) (Hirshfield v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-11-2001

OPINION

SWEET, District Judge.

Plaintiff Stuart Hirshfield and his wife, Susanne Hirshfield (the “Hirshfields”), have moved under Local Civil Rule 6.3 for reconsideration of the opinion of this Court dated May 30, 2001 (the “Opinion”), holding that it had no jurisdiction to consider their claim that the IRS notice for penalty and related interest was time-barred and that it was subject to the doctrine of

res judicata.

For the reasons set forth below, reconsideration is granted, and upon reconsideration partial summary judgment is granted in favor of the Hirshfields.

The “intricate web of procedures for ascertaining and adjusting partnership income for tax purposes, and for adjudicating related claims” (Opinion, p. 1) has developed yet another complicating and perplexing strand.

Both the Hirshfields and the United States (the “government”) agree that the jurisdictional bar raised by the Opinion was hoisted inappropriately.

As stated by the Hirshfields,

The jurisdictional question at issue turns on the definition of “partnership item.” Simply put, this Court has jurisdiction over refund suits attributable to non-partnership items but has no jurisdiction over suits for refunds attributable to partnership items.

(Memorandum of Law in Support of Plaintiffs’ Motion, p. 3).

The difficulty of interpreting complex tax statutes has been eloquently described by Judge Learned Hand of this Circuit.

See

Learned Hand,

Thomas Walter Swan,

57 Yale L.J. 167, 169 (1947).... Hence, the Court’s misapprehension with respect to the notice of deficiency for affected items is understandable, especially in light of the parties’ omission of any detailed discussion of the statutory classification of the penalty determination in their previous papers.

{Id.

at p. 8).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.