Washington Supreme Court May 24, 2001, 68520-7 (Samis Land Co. v. City of Soap Lake)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-05-2001
23 P.3d 477 (2001) SAMIS LAND CO., The Estate of Samuel Israel, and the Samuel Israel Living Trust, Respondents, v. CITY OF SOAP LAKE, Petitioner. No. 68520-7. Supreme Court of Washington, En Banc. Argued June 27, 2000. Decided May 24, 2001. *480 Foster, Pepper & Shefelman, Peter Stephen DiJulio, Grover E. Cleveland, Hugh Davidson Spitzer, Seattle, amicus curiae on behalf of Association of Wash. Cities and City of Ocean Shores. Greg Overstreet, Olympia, amicus curiae on behalf of Building Industry Association. Garvey, Schubert & Barer, William Colwell Severson, Seattle, amicus curiae on behalf of Ocean Shores Property Owners. City of Soap Lake, Soap Lake, Moe & Allan, Wallace Edward Allan, Ephrata, for Petitioner. Perkins, Coie, Scott M. Edwards, Seattle, for Respondent. *478 *479 BRIDGE, J. The issue here is whether a "standby charge" imposed by the City of Soap Lake upon vacant, unimproved, uninhabited lots that abut but are unconnected to its water and sewer lines is a regulatory fee or a property tax. We find that the charge is a property tax and that, because it is not assessed uniformly according to the respective values of the properties within the class, it violates article VII, section 1 of the Washington Constitution. We therefore affirm. FACTS Over the past three decades, respondents Samis Land Company, The Samuel Israel Living Trust, and the Estate of Samuel Israel (hereinafter, collectively, "Samis") have acquired approximately 200 platted, vacant lots in the City of Soap Lake ("City") and held the lots without significant development. In 1989, the City enacted Soap Lake Municipal Code (SLMC) 13.08.175, imposing a flat-rate $60 annual charge on any "vacant, unimproved land which shall abut a line providing water service or sewer service but have no connection thereto." Since 1990, Samis has paid the City more than $46,000 in standby charges. In February 1996, Samis stopped paying such charges in the wake of our decision in Covell v.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit