Court of Appeals of Oregon October 31, 2001, 16-98-01463; A105859 (US West Communications, Inc. v. City of Eugene)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-10-2001

*426

LANDAU, P. J.

US West Communications, Inc. (US West), initiated this action for declaratory and injunctive relief, challenging the validity of a telecommunications ordinance enacted by the City of Eugene (city). The company argued that the ordinance is preempted by one or more of a number of different state and federal laws. The trial court agreed and entered summary judgment for US West. The city appeals, and we reverse and remand.

The facts pertaining to the adoption of the challenged ordinance are set out in

AT&T Communications v. City of Eugene,

177 Or App 379, 381-84, 35 P3d 1029 (2001). Additional facts pertinent to this appeal are as follows.

US West is a telecommunications utility that provides a variety of telecommunications services to individuals and businesses in the city. Those services include local exchange access services as well as nonexchange access services such as call forwarding, call waiting, and caller identification. It uses city rights-of-way to provide some of its services. Since 1990, US West has been authorized to use those rights-of-way by a franchise agreement. The agreement is terminable by either party on 30 days’ notice; otherwise, it is scheduled to expire in 2005.

As described in detail in

AT&T Communications,

the city enacted a telecommunications ordinance in 1997 that requires all those who intend to provide telecommunications services within the city to complete a registration application and to pay a registration fee, including an annual fee equal to two percent of the provider’s “gross annual revenues” from telecommunications activities within the city. Eugene Code (EC) § 3.405(1); EC § 3.415(1). If providers use city rights-of-way, they are also required to complete an application demonstrating their legal, financial, and technical capabilities and must pay a license fee equal to seven percent of gross annual revenues. EC § 3.410(1); EC § 3.415(2).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.