Utah Supreme Court December 18, 2001, 20000476 (In Re the Discipline of Ennenga)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-12-2001

HOWE, Chief Justice.

INTRODUCTION

T1 The Office of Professional Conduct (OPC) of the Utah State Bar appeals from a judgment of the district court suspending attorney Peter M. Ennega from the practice of law for six months and placing him on probation for three years for violating rules 14, 1.15, 8.1, 8.1(b), 8.4(b), and 8.4(c) of the Utah Rules of Professional Conduct. Ennen-ga cross-appeals, asserting that the trial court's sanction order was erroneous because it violated the constitutional prohibition against the application of ex post facto laws in the context of criminal punishments.

BACKGROUND

12 Ennenga was licensed to practice law in Utah in 1970. The OPC filed a complaint for disciplinary action against him based on the allegations in the informal complaints to the OPC of four of Ennenga's clients: JoAnn Wilson, Taner Yarbil, Roduey Mover, and Alice Durrant-Funk. The trial court made the following findings on each matter.

13 In 1991, Ennenga was retained by JoAnn Wilson to collect $18,000 owed to her business; he collected the money in May 1992. Days after, Wilson requested that En-nega hold the money for her in an interest bearing escrow account. Instead of doing so, Ennenga deposited a portion of the money in his personal checking account in October 1992 and retained the rest of it in the form of a cashier's check. He then spent the entire amount of his client's money on personal expenses. Wilson's accountant requested an accounting of the $18,000 in April 1998, but Ennenga did not comply. Wilson's subsequent attempts to communicate with Ennen-ga regarding the money were answered with unfulfilled promises to pay and other evasive tactics.

{ 4 Taner Yarbil retained Ennenga in 1993 for a civil matter on a contingency fee basis. He gave Ennenga $750 of a $2,250 retainer, but Ennenga, without informing Yarbil, stopped any prosecution of the case after filing a complaint and serving one of the two defendants.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.