Colorado Court of Appeals December 3, 2001, 00CA0031 (Razi v. Schmitt)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-12-2001

Opinion by

Judge RULAND.

In this action to recover for damage to a commercial building resulting from a fire, defendant, Robert A. Schmitt, appeals from the judgment in favor of plaintiff, Mohammad A. Razi. We affirm in part, reverse in part, and remand the cause with directions.

Defendant started a series of fires in a commercial office building owned by plaintiff. The two-story building was rented to defendant's employer. The fires caused extensive damage. Only three of the four outside walls were salvageable.

Following his trial on arson charges, defendant paid all amounts ordered by the trial court in that case as restitution. This payment included $244,757.37 to plaintiff and plaintiff's insurance company.

Plaintiff then filed this action seeking additional compensatory and punitive damages. After a bench trial, the trial court awarded plaintiff additional compensatory damages in the sum of $390,580 for construction of a replacement building and for additional lost rent. In addition, the court awarded punitive damages in the sum of $250,000.

Between the insurance proceeds that plaintiff had already been paid via court-ordered restitution and the trial court's compensatory award, plaintiff would receive a total of $573,313 to replace the building.

According to defendant's expert, estimates of the building's value just prior to the fire ranged from $85,000 using the income approach to valuation to $210,000 using the cost approach. Based upon comparable sales, the value was placed at $185,000.

Plaintiff did not present evidence addressing diminution in market value, apparently as a result of the court's ruling on a pretrial summary judgment motion. Instead, plaintiff relied upon evidence of the cost to replace the building as the applicable measure of damages.

I.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.